What happens if a monk breaks the rules

This is a gift of Dhamma and must not be sold Revised: Fri 17 December Discipline is for the sake of restraint, restraint for the sake of freedom from remorse, freedom from remorse for the sake of joy, joy for the sake of rapture, rapture for the sake of tranquillity, tranquillity for the sake of pleasure, pleasure for the sake of concentration, concentration for the sake of knowledge and vision of things as they are, knowledge and vision of things as they are for the sake of disenchantment, disenchantment for the sake of release, release for the sake of knowledge and vision of release, knowledge and vision of release for the sake of total unbinding without clinging.

My aim has been to illustrate those of the monk's rules that also affect the lay person in some way. It was originally circulated as a computer printout, and its positive reception encouraged this complete reworking and revision, incorporating many of the suggestions sent to me. Even so, the best introduction remains a good practising bhikkhu who shows that amid the myriad things of the material world, living the simple life is possible with care -- hence the many rules -- much as in the Buddha's time.

The original Beginner's Questions section has been kept with some revision and moved to the front as a brief overview of the sort of questions covered in the book. It refers to later explanations for more detail, which can be found not only in the main text but in the End Notes, Footnotes, Glossary and Appendices. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Are there any punishments if a monk breaks vinaya rule on purpose..?

How does buddhism deal with vinaya rule breakers..? It lays down offences and punishments leading to a maximum of expulsion from the order. The punishment is typically decided by the Sangha, but the presiding abbot may decide on occasion when it is not feasible to assemble the sangha.

Some countries like Thailand have in the past got involved in the disciplining of monks because the monastic order itself wasn't doing enough, or because the state was outraged by certain infamous incidents. While it appears that punishments are generally very rare in most Buddhist countries, Japanese Zen monasteries are famous for offering very tough disciplinary punishments for the smallest of offences, often decided solely by the abbot.

So obviously culture has a large role to play in all this. However, monks have to adapt to new cultures and times - for example the monks and nuns of the Plum Village order in France under the tradition of Ven. Thich Nhat Hanh do their own cooking and even cook for lay people because it is nearly impossible to go on alms rounds in the countryside where they live.

The sub-questions related to the question do not arise. A person becomes a Pabbajita by makes a solemn promise by uttering:Buddham Saranam Gacchami, Dhammam Saranam Gacchami, Sangham Saranam Gacchami,three times after his teacher, according to a formal procedure. The procedure is same for Upasampada also. The responsibility for observing the Patimokkha rules rests with the Bhikkhu. If he breaks any of the rules he must purify himself before attending the next Uposatha.

If a dispute between two bhikkhus arise, then there is a procedure called Adhikarana to settle the matter. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Committing homicide Can. Procuring [i. In summary, monks and other religious, consecrated persons, and members of societies of apostolic life face in essence a maximum penalty of expulsion from their institute or society and, if they are priests or deacons, also reduction to the lay state for grave offenses against their vows.

They would not be obliged to copy manuscripts as a penance, and would certainly not be subject to cruel punishments such as being walled up. If such things occurred in the past, they are now entirely forbidden by Canon Law. A vow is defined as a promise made to God. The promise is binding, and so differs from a simple resolution which is a present purpose to do or omit certain things in the future.

Unlike the simple breach of a promise made to a man, a failure to give to God what has been promised Him is a matter of importance, a very serious offence. Unless the vow is annulled or one is dispensed from the obligation to fulfill it, after seeking God's forgiveness in the Sacrament of Reconciliation or Penance, the person who made the vow is still under the obligation to fulfill it. Since the vow is between the individual and God, I do not see the why and the how of the involvement the individual's monastic order or what the relevance of modern times would be upon the breaking of the vow.

Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. In modern times, what would happen to a Roman Catholic monk if he were to violate his monastic vows?

Ask Question. Asked 7 years, 2 months ago. Active 5 years, 11 months ago. Viewed 2k times. Improve this question. Double U Double U 6, 7 7 gold badges 42 42 silver badges 88 88 bronze badges. I started that documentary on Netflix just a few day's ago. Haven't gotten a chance to finish it yet though. The story you quote though was legend. They don't know who wrote it. The real story is that one monk agreed to work on what would become his magnum opus, the Codex Gigas.

Well, I didn't finish the documentary, but what I did see indicated that they do not know who wrote it or under what circumstances, but there is evidence that it was written by a single person.

Just to be certain, you are asking specifically what the ecclesiastical penalties are for a religious breaking his vows? Yes, I am asking specifically for what the ecclesiastical penalties are for the religious monastic who breaks his vows.

Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. For less serious faults, the monk or sister; the same Rule applies to both male and female communities shall take [his] food alone after the community meal, so that if they eat at the sixth hour, for instance, that [brother] shall eat at the ninth, while if they eat at the ninth hour [he] shall eat in the evening, until by a suitable satisfaction [he] obtains pardon.

Benedict", Chapter 24 If a more serious fault is involved, the monk is excluded both from the common meal time and from common worship time.

Further, no one is allowed to talk to him or even approach him: Let none of the brethren join him either for company or for conversation.

The second to last resort is to have the community pray for the afflicted brother, in the hope that the Lord will help where the Abbot cannot; but if even this doesn't work, the abbot is told to expel the monk from the monastery: But if [he] is not healed even in this way, then let the [Abbot] use the knife of amputation, according to the Apostle's words, "Expel the evil one from your midst" 1 Cor.

Improve this answer. Matt Gutting Matt Gutting Aloha Matt!